第 1 节
作者:
打倒一切 更新:2021-10-16 18:43 字数:8714
OF SUPERSTITION AND ENTHUSIASM
David Hume
1741
;
is grown into a maxim; and is commonly proved; among other
instances; by the pernicious effects of and
; the corruptions of true religion。
These two species of false religion; though both pernicious;
are yet of a very different; and even of a contrary nature。 The
mind of man is subject to certain unaccountable terrors and
apprehensions; proceeding either from the unhappy situation of
private or public affairs; from ill health; from a gloomy and
melancholy disposition; or from the concurrence of all these
circumstances。 In such a state of mind; infinite unknown evils
are dreaded from unknown agents; and where real objects of terror
are wanting; the soul; active to its own prejudice; and fostering
its predominant inclination; finds imaginary ones; to whose power
and malevolence it sets no limits。 As these enemies are entirely
invisible and unknown; the methods taken to appease them are
equally unaccountable; and consist in ceremonies; observances;
mortifications; sacrifices; presents; or in any practice; however
absurd or frivolous; which either folly or knavery recommends to
a blind and terrified credulity。 Weakness; fear; melancholy;
together with ignorance; are; therefore; the true sources of
Superstition。
But the mind of man is also subject to an unaccountable
elevation and presumption; arising from prosperous success; from
luxuriant health; from strong spirits; or from a bold and
confident disposition。 In such a state of mind; the imagination
swells with great; but confused conceptions; to which no
sublunary beauties or enjoyments can correspond。 Every thing
mortal and perishable vanishes as unworthy of attention。 And a
full range is given to the fancy in the invisible regions or
world of spirits; where the soul is at liberty to indulge itself
in every imagination; which may best suit its present taste and
disposition。 Hence arise raptures; transports; and surprising
flights of fancy; and confidence and presumption still
encreasing; these raptures; being altogether unaccountable; and
seeming quite beyond the reach of our ordinary faculties; are
attributed to the immediate inspiration of that Divine Being; who
is the object of devotion。 In a little time; the inspired person
comes to regard himself as a distinguished favourite of the
Divinity; and when this frenzy once takes place; which is the
summit of enthusiasm; every whimsy is consecrated: Human reason;
and even morality are rejected as fallacious guides: And the
fanatic madman delivers himself over; blindly; and with out
reserve; to the supposed illapses of the spirit; and to
inspiration from above。 Hope; pride; presumption; a warm
imagination; together with ignorance; are; therefore; the true
sources of Enthusiasm。
These two species of false religion might afford occasion to
many speculations; but I shall confine myself; at present; to a
few reflections concerning their different influence on
government and society。
My first reflection is; 。 As superstition is
founded on fear; sorrow; and a depression of spirits; it
represents the man to himself in such despicable colours; that he
appears unworthy; in his own eyes; of approaching the divine
presence; and naturally has recourse to any other person; whose
sanctity of life; or; perhaps; impudence and cunning; have made
him be supposed more favoured by the Divinity。 To him the
superstitious entrust their devotions: To his care they recommend
their prayers; petitions; and sacrifices: And by his means; they
hope to render their addresses acceptable to their incensed
Deity。 Hence the origin of Priests;'2' who may justly be regarded
as an invention of a timorous and abject superstition; which;
ever diffident of itself; dares not offer up its own devotions;
but ignorantly thinks to recommend itself to the Divinity; by the
mediation of his supposed friends and servants。 As superstition
is a considerable ingredient in almost all religions; even the
most fanatical; there being nothing but philosophy able entirely
to conquer these unaccountable terrors; hence it proceeds; that
in almost every sect of religion there are priests to be found:
But the stronger mixture there is of superstition; the higher is
the authority of the priesthood。'3'
On the other hand; it may be observed; that all enthusiasts
have been free from the yoke of ecclesiastics; and have expressed
great independence in their devotion; with a contempt of forms;
ceremonies; and traditions。 The quakers are the most egregious;
though; at the same time; the most innocent enthusiasts that have
yet been known; and are; perhaps; the only sect; that have never
admitted priests amongst them。 The independents; of all the
English sectaries; approach nearest to the quakers in fanaticism;
and in their freedom from priestly bondage。 The presbyterians
follow after; at an equal distance in both particulars。 In short
this observation is founded in experience; and will also appear
to be founded in reason; if we consider; that; as enthusiasm
arises from a presumptuous pride and confidence; it thinks itself
sufficiently qualified to approach the Divinity; without any
human mediator。 Its rapturous devotions are so fervent; that it
even imagines itself actually to approach him by the way of
contemplation and inward converse; which makes it neglect all
those outward ceremonies and observances; to which the assistance
of the priests appears so requisite in the eyes of their
superstitious votaries。 The fanatic consecrates himself; and
bestows on his own person a sacred character; much superior to
what forms and ceremonious institutions can confer on any other。
My reflection with regard to these species of false
religion is; 。 The violence of this species of religion; when
excited by novelty; and animated by opposition; appears from
numberless instances; of the in Germany; the
in France; the l and other fanatics in
England and the in Scotland。 Enthusiasm being
founded on strong spirits; and a presumptuous boldness of
character; it naturally begets the most extreme resolutions;
especially after it rises to that height as to inspire the
deluded fanatic with the opinion of divine illuminations; and
with a contempt for the common rules of reason; morality; and
prudence。
It is thus enthusiasm produces the most cruel disorders in
human society; but its fury is like that of thunder and tempest;
which exhaust themselves in a little time; and leave the air more
calm and pure than before。 When the first fire of enthusiasm is
spent; men naturally; in all fanatical sects; sink into the
greatest remissness and coolness in sacred matters; there being
no body of men among them; endowed with sufficient authority;
whose interest is concerned to support the religious spirit: No
rites; no ceremonies; no holy observances; which may enter into
the common train of life; and preserve the sacred principles from
oblivion。 Superstition; on the contrary; steals in gradually and
insensibly; renders men tame and submissive; is acceptable to the
magistrate; and seems inoffensive to the people: Till at last the
priest; having firmly established his authority; becomes the
tyrant and disturber of human society; by his endless
contentions; persecutions; and religious wars。 How smoothly did
the Romish church advance in her acquisition of power ? But into
what dismal convulsions did she throw all Europe; in order to
maintain it ? On the other hand; our sectaries; who were formerly
such dangerous bigots; are now become very free reasoners; and
the seem to approach nearly the only regular body of
in the universe; the l; or the disciples of
Confucius in China。'4'
My observation on this head is; 。 As
superstition groans under the dominion of priests; and enthusiasm
is destructive of all ecclesiastical power; this sufficiently
accounts for the present observation。 Not to mention; that
enthusiasm; being the infirmity of bold and ambitious tempers; is
naturally accompanied with a spirit of liberty; as superstition;
on the contrary; renders men tame and abject; and fits them for
slavery。 We learn from English history; that; during the civil
wars; the and