expressions　in　question　are　distinctly　and　invariably　employed　just
  as　I　have　employed　them　in　this　conversation　with　yourself；　no　notice
  whatever　of　the　gross　discrepancy　has；　as　yet；　been　taken　by　any　of
  the　public　journals；　or　by　any　of　the　Myrmidons　of　police。
  〃I　shall　add　but　one　to　the　arguments　against　a　gang；　but　this　one
  has；　to　my　own　understanding　at　least；　a　weight　altogether
  irresistible。　Under　the　circumstances　of　large　reward　offered；　and
  full　pardon　to　any　King's　evidence；　it　is　not　to　be　imagined；　for　a
  moment；　that　some　member　of　a　gang　of　low　ruffians；　or　of　any　body　of
  men；　would　not　long　ago　have　betrayed　his　accomplices。　Each　one　of　a
  gang　so　placed；　is　not　so　much　greedy　of　reward；　or　anxious　for
  escape；　as　fearful　of　betrayal。　He　betrays　eagerly　and　early　that　he
  may　not　himself　be　betrayed。　That　the　secret　has　not　been　divulged；
  is　the　very　best　of　proof　that　it　is；　in　fact；　a　secret。　The　horrors
  of　this　dark　deed　are　known　only　to　one；　or　two；　living　human　beings；
  and　to　God。
  〃Let　us　sum　up　now　the　meagre　yet　certain　fruits　of　our　long
  analysis。　We　have　attained　the　idea　either　of　a　fatal　accident　under
  the　roof　of　Madame　Deluc；　or　of　a　murder　perpetrated；　in　the　thicket
  at　the　Barri鑢e　du　Roule；　by　a　lover；　or　at　least　by　an　intimate　and
  secret　associate　of　the　deceased。　This　associate　is　of　swarthy
  complexion。　This　complexion；　the　'hitch'　in　the　bandage；　and　the
  'sailor's　knot；'　with　which　the　bonnet…ribbon　is　tied；　point　to　a
  seaman。　His　companionship　with　the　deceased；　a　gay；　but　not　an　abject
  young　girl；　designates　him　as　above　the　grade　of　the　common　sailor。
  Here　the　well　written　and　urgent　communications　to　the　journals　are
  much　in　the　way　of　corroboration。　The　circumstance　of　the　first
  elopement；　as　mentioned　by　Le　Mercurie；　tends　to　blend　the　idea　of
  this　seaman　with　that　of　the　'naval　officer'　who　is　first　known　to
  have　led　the　unfortunate　into　crime。
  〃And　here；　most　fitly；　comes　the　consideration　of　the　continued
  absence　of　him　of　the　dark　complexion。　Let　me　pause　to　observe　that
  the　complexion　of　this　man　is　dark　and　swarthy；　it　was　no　common
  swarthiness　which　constituted　the　sole　point　of　remembrance；　both　as
  regards　Valence　and　Madame　Deluc。　But　why　is　this　man　absent？　Was　he
  murdered　by　the　gang？　If　so；　why　are　there　only　traces　of　the
  assassinated　girl？　The　scene　of　the　two　outrages　will　naturally　be
  supposed　identical。　And　where　is　his　corpse？　The　assassins　would　most
  probably　have　disposed　of　both　in　the　same　way。　But　it　may　be　said
  that　this　man　lives；　and　is　deterred　from　making　himself　known；
  through　dread　of　being　charged　with　the　murder。　This　consideration
  might　be　supposed　to　operate　upon　him　now　…　at　this　late　period　…
  since　it　has　been　given　in　evidence　that　he　was　seen　with　Marie　…　but
  it　would　have　had　no　force　at　the　period　of　the　deed。　The　first
  impulse　of　an　innocent　man　would　have　been　to　announce　the　outrage；
  and　to　aid　in　identifying　the　ruffians。　This　policy　would　have
  suggested。　He　had　been　seen　with　the　girl。　He　had　crossed　the　river
  with　her　in　an　open　ferry…boat。　The　denouncing　of　the　assassins　would
  have　appeared；　even　to　an　idiot；　the　surest　and　sole　means　of
  relieving　himself　from　suspicion。　We　cannot　suppose　him；　on　the　night
  of　the　fatal　Sunday；　both　innocent　himself　and　incognizant　of　an
  outrage　committed。　Yet　only　under　such　circumstances　is　it　possible
  to　imagine　that　he　would　have　failed；　if　alive；　in　the　denouncement
  of　the　assassins。
  〃And　what　means　are　ours；　of　attaining　the　truth？　We　shall　find　these
  means　multiplying　and　gathering　distinctness　as　we　proceed。　Let　us
  sift　to　the　bottom　this　affair　of　the　first　elopement。　Let　us　know
  the　full　history　of　'the　officer；'　with　his　present　circumstances；
  and　his　whereabouts　at　the　precise　period　of　the　murder。　Let　us
  carefully　compare　with　each　other　the　various　communications　sent　to
  the　evening　paper；　in　which　the　object　was　to　inculpate　a　gang。　This
  done；　let　us　compare　these　communications；　both　as　regards　style　and
  MS。；　with　those　sent　to　the　morning　paper；　at　a　previous　period；　and
  insisting　so　vehemently　upon　the　guilt　of　Mennais。　And；　all　this
  done；　let　us　again　compare　these　various　communications　with　the
  known　MSS。　of　the　officer。　Let　us　endeavor　to　ascertain；　by　repeated
  questionings　of　Madame　Deluc　and　her　boys；　as　well　as　of　the　omnibus
  driver；　Valence；　something　more　of　the　personal　appearance　and
  bearing　of　the　'man　of　dark　complexion。'　Queries；　skilfully　directed；
  will　not　fail　to　elicit；　from　some　of　these　parties；　information　on
  this　particular　point　（or　upon　others）　…　information　which　the
  parties　themselves　may　not　even　be　aware　of　possessing。　And　let　us
  now　trace　the　boatpicked　up　by　the　bargeman　on　the　morning　of　Monday
  the　twenty…third　of　June；　and　which　was　removed　from　the
  barge…office；　without　the　cognizance　of　the　officer　in　attendance；
  and　without　the　rudder；　at　some　period　prior　to　the　discovery　of　the
  corpse。　With　a　proper　caution　and　perseverance　we　shall　infallibly
  trace　this　boat；　for　not　only　can　the　bargeman　who　picked　it　up
  identify　it；　but　the　rudder　is　at　hand。　The　rudder　of　a　sail…boat
  would　not　have　been　abandoned；　without　inquiry；　by　one　altogether　at
  ease　in　heart。　And　here　let　me　pause　to　insinuate　a　question。　There
  was　no　advertisement　of　the　picking　up　of　this　boat。　It　was　silently
  taken　to　the　barge…office；　and　as　silently　removed。　But　its　owner　or
  employer　…　how　happened　he；　at　so　early　a　period　as　Tuesday　morning；
  to　be　informed；　without　the　agency　of　advertisement；　of　the　locality
  of　the　boat　taken　up　on　Monday；　unless　we　imagine　some　connexion　with
  the　navy　…　some　personal　permanent　connexion　leading　to　cognizance　of
  its　minute　in　interests　…　its　petty　local　news？
  〃In　speaking　of　the　lonely　assassin　dragging　his　burden　to　the　shore；
  I　have　already　suggested　the　probability　of　his　availing　himself　of　a
  boat。　Now　we　are　to　understand　that　Marie　Rog阾　was　precipitated　from
  a　boat。　This　would　naturally　have　been　the　case。　The　corpse　could　not
  have　been　trusted　to　the　shallow　waters　of　the　shore。　The　peculiar
  marks　on　the　back　and　shoulders　of　the　victim　tell　of　the　bottom　ribs
  of　a　boat。　That　the　body　was　found　without　weight　is　also
  corroborative　of　the　idea。　If　thrown　from　the　shore　a　weight　would
  have　been　attached。　We　can　only　account　for　its　absence　by　supposing
  the　murderer　to　have　neglected　the　precaution　of　supplying　himself
  with　it　before　pushing　off。　In　the　act　of　consigning　the　corpse　to
  the　water；　he　would　unquestionably　have　noticed　his　oversight；　but
  then　no　remedy　would　have　been　at　hand。　Any　risk　would　have　been
  preferred　to　a　return　to　that　accursed　shore。　Having　rid　himself　of
  his　ghastly　charge；　the　murderer　would　have　hastened　to　the　city。
  There；　at　some　obscure　wharf；　he　would　have　leaped　on　land。　But　the
  boat　…　would　he　have　secured　it？　He　would　have　been　in　too　great
  haste　for　such　things　as　securing　a　boat。　Moreover；　in　fastening　it
  to　the　wharf；　he　would　have　felt　as　if　securing　evidence　against
  himself。　His　natural　thought　would　have　been　to　cast　from　him；　as　far
  as　possible；　all　that　had　held　connection　with　his　crime。　He　would
  not　only　have　fled　from　the　wharf；　but　he　would　not　have　permitted
  the　boat　to　remain。　Assuredly　he　would　have　cast　it　adrift。　Let　us
  pursue　our　fancies。　…　In　the　morning；　the　wretch　is　stricken　with
  unutterable　horror　at　finding　that　the　boat　has　been　picked　up　and
  detained　at　a　locality　which　he　is　in　the　daily　habit　of　frequenting
  …　at　a　locality；　perhaps；　which　his　duty　compels　him　to　frequent。　The
  next　night；　without　daring　to　ask　for　the　rudder；　he　removes　it。　Now
  where　is　that　rudderless　boat？　Let　it　be　one　of　our　first　purposes　to
  discover。　With　the　first　glimpse　we　obtain　of　it；　the　dawn　of　our
  success　shall　begin。　This　boat　shall　guide　us；　with　a　rapidity　which
  will　surprise　even　ourselves；　to　him　who　employed　it　in　the　midnight
  of　the　fatal　Sabbath。　Corroboration　will　rise　upon　corroboration；　and
  the　murderer　will　be　traced。〃
  ＇For　reasons　which　we　shall　not　specify；　but　which　to　many　readers
  will　appear　obvious；　we　have　taken　the　liberty　of　here　omitting；　from
  the　MSS。　placed　in　our　hands；　such　portion　as　details　the　following
  up　of　the　apparently　slight　clew　obtained　by　Dupin。　We　feel　it
  advisable　only　to　state；　in　brief；　that　the　result　desired　was
  brought　to　pass；　and　that　the　Prefect　fulfilled　punctually；　although
  with　reluctance；　the　terms　of　his　compact　with　the　Chevalier。　Mr。
  Poe's　article　concludes　with　the　following　words。　…　Eds。　｛*23｝＇
  It　will　be　understood　that　I　speak　of　coincidences　and　no　more。　What
  I　have　said　above　upon　this　topic　must　suffice。　In　my　own　heart　there
  dwells　no　faith　in　pr鎡er…nature。　That　Nature　and　its　God　are　two；　no
  man　who　thinks；　will　deny。　That　the　latter；　creating　the　former；　can；
  at　will；　control　or　modify　it；　is　also　unquestionable。　I　say　〃at
  will；〃　for　the　question　is　of　will；　and　not；　as　the　insanity　of　logic
  has　assumed；　of　power。　It　is　not　that　the　Deity　cannot　modify　his
  laws；　but　tha