第 1 节
作者:雨帆      更新:2021-02-24 23:13      字数:9321
  Modern Customs and Ancient Laws of Russia
  by Maxime Kovalevsky
  1891
  Lecture I
  The Matrimonial Customs and Usages of the Russian People; and the
  Light They Throw on the Evolution of Marriage
  The wide historical studies pursued by members of the
  University of Oxford necessarily include the study of the
  Slavonic race。 The part which this race is beginning to play in
  the economic and social progress of our time; and the
  considerable achievements which it has already made in the fields
  of literature and science have attracted the attention even of
  those nations whose political interests are supposed not to
  coincide precisely with those of the Slavs。 The Ilchester
  Lectures were; I believe; founded in order to make known to
  Oxford students the present and past of this undoubtedly Aryan
  branch of the human race。 A good deal of work has already been
  done by my predecessors。 Professor Thomson; of Copenhagen; by his
  careful study of the Norman origin of the Russian State; has
  greatly contributed to unveil even to Russians the mystery of
  their far…distant past; while Professor Turner; in the course of
  his brilliant lectures last year; made you acquainted with our
  best modern novelists。 I do not know if my friend; the late Mr
  W。R。S。 Ralston; ever lectured in the Taylor institute; but the
  accurate and lively accounts he has given of Russian epic poems
  and popular tales were undoubtedly written under the influence of
  the same feelings as those which inspired the founder of these
  lectures。
  In England the works of Ralston were the first to deal with
  the vast field of Slavonic; and more especially of Russian;
  folk…lore。 His chief endeavour was to show the great amount of
  information which the unwritten literature of Russia contains as
  to the early stages of religious development。 But Russian
  folk…lore may interest a lawyer as well as a mythologist; its
  study may enrich comparative jurisprudence with new material not
  less than comparative mythology。 It can no doubt unveil more than
  one mystery concerning the early state of European family law;
  and the various modes in which land was held by our remotest
  ancestors。 The first stages in the history of political
  institutions; and more particularly the part which the common
  people were called upon in old days to play in the management of
  public affairs; can be illustrated by the history of Russian
  folk…motes and Russian national councils; much better than by
  reference to the short notices left by Caesar or Tacitus of the
  popular assemblies of the Germans。 Russian serfdom; and the
  history of its abolition; may also be instructive in more than
  one point; even to those whose chief purpose is to study the
  origin; the growth; and the abolition of personal servitude in
  England; France; or Germany。
  When I look to the great importance of the modern customs and
  ancient laws of Russia as regards the comparative history of
  institutions; I confidently hope to meet on your part with the
  indulgence which the lecturer needs who addresses his audience in
  a foreign tongue。 I think that the study of Russian legal
  antiquities may to a certain extent be considered as a necessary
  appendage of those exhaustive inquiries in Indian and old Celtic
  institutions for which we are indebted to one of your most
  celebrated writers; the late Sir Henry Maine。 I feel the more
  pleasure in mentioning his name; as it was by him that my first
  works in the field of comparative jurisprudence were inspired。
  His lectures have found readers in the remotest parts of the
  world; and have suggested to more than one foreign scholar the
  idea of re…writing the legal history of his own country。
  Although recognising in him the chief representative of the
  legal school to which I belong; I shall more than once put
  forward theories which are altogether opposed to his: such an
  occasion presents itself at once in the study of early Russian
  family law。
  This study will; I have no doubt; throw a clear light on the
  earliest period in the evolution of marriage  that of the
  matriarchate。 I insist the more on this point because in England
  an opinion has been expressed that the customary law of Russia
  might be expected to give another illustration of the general
  prevalence of the patriarchal family even in the first stages of
  social development。 Sir Henry Maine has more than once(1*)
  expressed this opinion; and has found confirmation for it in
  certain quotations made chiefly from the well…known works of
  Haxthausen and Mackenzie Wallace。 Both these authors; making a
  large use of the rich ethnographical literature of Russia; have
  correctly described the prevailing system of Russian joint
  families; or house communities; and their account may be taken
  generally as a good illustration of the old patriarchal family of
  the Germans and Celts。 But neither of them had any opportunity of
  studying in detail the numerous survivals which we still find of
  a state of things which had nothing in common with agnatism; or
  even with a firmly established 〃patria potestas。〃 Such was not;
  after all; the purpose that they had in view。 Theirs was the
  study of contemporary life in Russian society; and the question
  of the primitive state of family relations in Russia cannot be
  settled by reference to works which do not deal with the subject。
  Sir Henry Maine was also misled in his survey of Slavonic
  family law by the well…known Bohemian or Czech poem; 〃The Trial
  of the Princess Liuhouscha。〃 This poem he quotes at great length;
  and he states that it leaves no doubt as to the existence of a
  sort of undivided family or house…community in the most remote
  period of Bohemian history。 Unfortunately; the poem on which he
  builds his conclusion is now unanimously declared both by
  Slavonic and German scholars to be a forgery by the well…known
  Bohemian philologist; Hanka。 It is clear; therefore; that the
  whole of his theory; so far as it deals with Slavonic law and
  usage; is based either on facts which concern modern times alone;
  and have nothing to do with ancient times; or on documents
  manifestly false。
  Now let us see what evidence we possess as to the character
  of early Slavonic family law。 We shall first give our
  authorities; and then proceed to draw our general conclusions。
  The earliest evidence which we possess as to the social
  relations of the Eastern Slavs; whose confederacy was the
  beginning of the Russian State; is contained in the so…called
  Chronicle of Nestor。 Nestor is supposed to have been a Russian
  monk of the eleventh century。
  Contrasting the mode of life of the most civilised Slavonic
  nation; the Polians; who were established on the banks of the
  Dnieper; with that of the more barbarous tribes of Russia;
  Nestor; or perhaps it is better to say; the unknown author of the
  Chronicle which bears this name; states as follows (I translate
  literally): 〃Each tribe had its own customs; and the laws of its
  forefathers and its own traditions; each its own manner of life
  (nrav)。 The Polians had the customs of their fathers; customs
  mild and peaceful (tichi); they showed a kind of reserve
  (stidenie) towards the daughters of their sons and towards their
  sisters; towards their mothers and their parents; towards the
  mothers of their wives; and towards the brothers of their
  husbands; to all of the persons named they showed great reserve。
  Amongst them the bridegroom did not go to seek his bride; she was
  taken to him in the evening; and the following morning they
  brought what was given for her。〃
  〃Another Slavonic tribe; the Drevlians; according to the same
  chronicler; lived like beasts; they killed one another; they fed
  on things unclean; no marriage took place amongst them; but they
  captured young girls on the banks of rivers。〃
  The same author narrates that three other Slavonic tribes;
  the Radimich; the Viatich; and the Sever; had the same customs;
  they lived 〃in forests; like other wild animals; they ate
  everything unclean; and shameful things occurred amongst them
  between fathers and daughters…in…law。 Marriages were unknown to
  them; but games were held in the outskirts of villages; they met
  at these games for dancing and every kind of diabolic amusement;
  and there they captured their wives; each man the one he had
  covenanted with。 They had generally two or three wives。〃
  I have tried to give you the nearest possible translation of
  this old Russian text; the interpretation of which; however;
  gives rise to certain difficulties not yet quite settled。 I will
  now classify; to the best of my power; the various facts which we
  can infer from this text。 First of all; it establishes the fact
  that marriage in the sense of a constant union between husband
  and wife; was not a general institution among the Eastern Slavs。
  With the exception of the more civilised Polians; no other tribe
  is stated to have any notion of it。 Of course this does not mean
  that all alike were entirely ignorant of the meaning of family
  life。 It only weans that their mode of constituting a family did
  not correspond to the idea which the author; who; as we have
  said; was a monk; entertained as to matrimonial relations。 The
  Radimich; Viatich;