第 47 节
作者:
暖暖 更新:2021-02-24 23:00 字数:9322
en of the statement or implication in a subtle or gross way that they are charming; and the effect on men of acknowledged superiority in strength courage or intelligence。 Of course; in both cases the effect is partly in the physical attractiveness of the flatterer and tends to become ridiculous when he or she is without charm。 The simpering language that is irresistible when uttered by a starry…eyed maid of eighteen loses somewhat in beauty and effect when emanating from the lips of bespectacled forty。 The power to use and the power to resist flattery in any of its forms have played almost as great a role in the history of the race as strength; beauty or intelligence。 It would be futile to elaborate in detail the various ways of seeking superiority or resisting inferiority。 Two directions of this impulse need some attention; as they lead to personality traits of great importance。 〃Having one's way〃 becomes a dominant desire with many people; and much of the clashing that occurs in families; organizations and the council chambers of nations arises from a childish; egoistic seeking of superiority。 People enter into the most heated and sterile arguments; often coming to blows; if the course of conduct they desire to have followed is modified or blocked。 Even when secretly convinced that they are wrong; husbands and wives will continue to insist on victory; for too often the domestic relationship is a struggle for leadership and dominance rather than a partnership and a conference。 Two heads are better than one when the intelligence within the heads is of good grade and when the desire for superiority does not take trivial directions。 And the effect of yielding to the whims of children is to develop an irritable; domineering egoism bent on having its own way; resisting reasonable compromise or correction。 The greatest benefit of discipline and above all of contact with equals to a child is in the effect on this phase of egoism; i。 e。; that cooperation means compromise; to be reasonable implies listening with respect to others' plans and to accept better ways of doing things; even if they have originated with others; in other ways the subordinating of trivial egoism。 The large families of other days offered the conflict of wills and its consequent lesson within the home; to…day the solitary child; or the one whose brother or sister is three; four or five years younger or older must go into the streets to obtain this discipline or else go without。 The indulged have this form of inferior egoism more than do those who have been roughly handled; and so it is more common in women of the better…to…do classes and in men who have always exercised authority。 It is of course found in what is known as the stubborn person; he whose will is law to himself and who seeks to make it law to others。 Ordinarily the stubborn person is merely a nuisance; but also; if he couples that stubbornness with intelligence and some especial ability; he may reach great heights; though he is seldom popular。 A sub…form of having one's own way is the adherence to one's own 〃opinion。〃 The clash of opinions is in its noblest aspect the basis of knowledge; the correction of opinion that results when man meets man is the growth of tolerance and urbanity。 Wide reading; travel and experience teach us that our opinions can never be absolutely right; and we grow to look upon them in a detached sort of way。 In fact; the prime result of the growth of intelligence and of experience is to make one; as it were; objective toward oneself; to view one's own thoughts; beliefs and emotions with some humor and skepticism。 But the uncultured; the narrow; the inexperienced; the young and the strongly egotistic never detach themselves from their opinions; and their opinions are themselves。 Attack an opinion; contradict or amend it;and a sort of fighting spirit is aroused。 Argument differs from discussion in that it seeks all means to winridicule; sophistry; and personal attack and it is by far the more common。 There was a time when opinion was entirely enslaved; when only the ruler might venture on a new belief or its expression; then there came a time when the right to freedom of opinion and its expression was conceded; and now; with huge forces confronting one another; freedom of opinion'1' is again threatened。 But that is an issue larger than our subject。 '1' The most profound contribution to the subject of discussion and freedom of opinion in recent years has been written by Walter Lippman in the Atlantic Monthly; September; 1920。
You may judge a man by his type of argument and his reaction to the opinions of others。 One should hold to his own beliefs and opinions; but only if they withstand the assaults of reason。 To build ego feeling into opinions is to make ignorance sacred。 For most of us there are certain opinions that we will not tolerate; and there are others to which we are indifferent。 There are those who feel it incumbent on themselves to contradict any opinion; even if they agree fundamentally with it。 The mere fact that some one else gave it utterance arouses a sort of jealousy。 Then there are others who will not permit any opinion of their own to be discussed; to whom it is a personal affront to do this。 What we call urbanity is tolerance of other opinions; what we call reasonableness is the willingness to change opinions if convinced。 What we call vacillation is to have no fixed opinion; to be influenced at once by the opinions of others。 The pleasure sought in argument is a victory for our opinions and thus for ourselves。 Here Montaigne's wisdom aptly expresses itself: 〃We deride ourselves a hundred times when we mock our neighbor。〃 He is stubborn and unreasonable who does not agree with us。 〃Be reasonable;〃 cry the unreasonable as they argue。 〃How stubborn and pigheaded you are;〃 say those inaccessible to reason。 The difficulty in reaching a true estimate of the world; ourselves and our neighbors lies in the egoism which permeates our beliefs and opinions。 A second direction of the impulse to superiority is personal beauty。 Not only does the young girl (or any other; male or female) dress and adorn herself to attract those whose good opinion she seeks; but also she seeks superiority over her competitors。 Her own self…valuation increases with the admiration of some and the discomfiture of others。 To be beautiful; attractive or pretty becomes thus a goal to many aims of the personality; it offers a route to success in obtaining power; riches; etc。; it yields the longed…for admiration; and it gives the satisfaction of superiority。 It rarely has in it any ideal of service or of help; though beauty in the abstract is an ideal of high value。 To desire to be beautiful physically as a leading aim usually leads to selfishness and petty vanity。 As a subsidiary aim it balances character; but unfortunately; as we have before seen; it is inculcated as a primary aim early in the life of a girl。 True; men seek to be beautiful in a masculine way; but the goal of masculine beauty is strength; which is directly serviceable。 This is not to say that there are no men who are vain of their good looks; for there are many。 But only occasionally does one find a man who organizes his life efforts to be beautiful; who establishes criteria of success or failure on complexion; hair; features of face and lines of figure。 So long; therefore; as woman can obtain power through beauty and sex appeal; so long may we expect a trivial trend in her character。 We have lost track of our hypothetical child in the history of his character development; lost sight of him as he struggles in a morass of desires and purposes of power; fellowship and superiority。 His situations become still more complex as we watch him seek to unify his life around permanent purposes; against a pestering; surging; recurring; temporary desire。 He desires; let us say; to conform to the restriction in sex; but as he approaches adolescence; within and without stimuli of breathless ardor assail him。 He must inhibit them if he proposes to be chaste; and his continent road is beset with never…resting temptations。 He calls himself a fool at times for resisting; and his mind pictures the delights he missesif not from direct experience; from information he gathers in books and from those who knowand if he yields; then self…reproach embitters him。 But correctly to portray the situation is to drop our hypothetical adolescent; for here is where individual reaction and individual situations are too varied to be met with in one case。 Some do not inhibit their sex desires at all; others resist now and then; others yield occasionally; still others remain faithful to the ideal。 Some drop the conventional ideal and replace with unconventional substitutes; some resist at great cost to themselves; and others find no difficulty in resisting what is no temptation at all to them。 Passion; resistance; opportunity; training and sublimation differ as remarkably as nuns differ from prostitutes。 A similar situation is found in the work purposes。 To work steadily; with industry and unflagging effort; at something perhaps not inherently attractive is not merely a measure of energy;it is a measure of inhibition and will。 For there are so many more immediate pleasures to b