may　be　more　accurately　put　by　saying　that　each　one　of　these　Christian
  or　mystical　virtues　involves　a　paradox　in　its　own　nature；　and　that　this
  is　not　true　of　any　of　the　typically　pagan　or　rationalist　virtues。
  Justice　consists　in　finding　out　a　certain　thing　due　to　a　certain　man
  and　giving　it　to　him。　　Temperance　consists　in　finding　out　the　proper
  limit　of　a　particular　indulgence　and　adhering　to　that。　　But　charity
  means　pardoning　what　is　unpardonable；　or　it　is　no　virtue　at　all。
  Hope　means　hoping　when　things　are　hopeless；　or　it　is　no　virtue　at　all。
  And　faith　means　believing　the　incredible；　or　it　is　no　virtue　at　all。
  It　is　somewhat　amusing；　indeed；　to　notice　the　difference　between
  the　fate　of　these　three　paradoxes　in　the　fashion　of　the　modern　mind。
  Charity　is　a　fashionable　virtue　in　our　time；　it　is　lit　up　by　the
  gigantic　firelight　of　Dickens。　　Hope　is　a　fashionable　virtue　to…day；
  our　attention　has　been　arrested　for　it　by　the　sudden　and　silver
  trumpet　of　Stevenson。　　But　faith　is　unfashionable；　and　it　is　customary
  on　every　side　to　cast　against　it　the　fact　that　it　is　a　paradox。
  Everybody　mockingly　repeats　the　famous　childish　definition　that　faith
  is　〃the　power　of　believing　that　which　we　know　to　be　untrue。〃
  Yet　it　is　not　one　atom　more　paradoxical　than　hope　or　charity。
  Charity　is　the　power　of　defending　that　which　we　know　to　be　indefensible。
  Hope　is　the　power　of　being　cheerful　in　circumstances　which　we　know
  to　be　desperate。　　It　is　true　that　there　is　a　state　of　hope　which　belongs
  to　bright　prospects　and　the　morning；　but　that　is　not　the　virtue　of　hope。
  The　virtue　of　hope　exists　only　in　earthquake　and；　eclipse。
  It　is　true　that　there　is　a　thing　crudely　called　charity；　which　means
  charity　to　the　deserving　poor；　but　charity　to　the　deserving　is　not
  charity　at　all；　but　justice。　　It　is　the　undeserving　who　require　it；
  and　the　ideal　either　does　not　exist　at　all；　or　exists　wholly　for　them。
  For　practical　purposes　it　is　at　the　hopeless　moment　that　we　require
  the　hopeful　man；　and　the　virtue　either　does　not　exist　at　all；
  or　begins　to　exist　at　that　moment。　　Exactly　at　the　instant
  when　hope　ceases　to　be　reasonable　it　begins　to　be　useful。
  Now　the　old　pagan　world　went　perfectly　straightforward　until　it
  discovered　that　going　straightforward　is　an　enormous　mistake。
  It　was　nobly　and　beautifully　reasonable；　and　discovered　in　its
  death…pang　this　lasting　and　valuable　truth；　a　heritage　for　the　ages；
  that　reasonableness　will　not　do。　　The　pagan　age　was　truly　an　Eden
  or　golden　age；　in　this　essential　sense；　that　it　is　not　to　be　recovered。
  And　it　is　not　to　be　recovered　in　this　sense　again　that；
  while　we　are　certainly　jollier　than　the　pagans；　and　much
  more　right　than　the　pagans；　there　is　not　one　of　us　who　can；
  by　the　utmost　stretch　of　energy；　be　so　sensible　as　the　pagans。
  That　naked　innocence　of　the　intellect　cannot　be　recovered
  by　any　man　after　Christianity；　and　for　this　excellent　reason；
  that　every　man　after　Christianity　knows　it　to　be　misleading。
  Let　me　take　an　example；　the　first　that　occurs　to　the　mind；　of　this
  impossible　plainness　in　the　pagan　point　of　view。　　The　greatest
  tribute　to　Christianity　in　the　modern　world　is　Tennyson's　〃Ulysses。〃
  The　poet　reads　into　the　story　of　Ulysses　the　conception　of　an　incurable
  desire　to　wander。　　But　the　real　Ulysses　does　not　desire　to　wander　at　all。
  He　desires　to　get　home。　　He　displays　his　heroic　and　unconquerable
  qualities　in　resisting　the　misfortunes　which　baulk　him；　but　that　is　all。
  There　is　no　love　of　adventure　for　its　own　sake；　that　is　a
  Christian　product。　　There　is　no　love　of　Penelope　for　her　own　sake；
  that　is　a　Christian　product。　　Everything　in　that　old　world　would
  appear　to　have　been　clean　and　obvious。　　A　good　man　was　a　good　man；
  a　bad　man　was　a　bad　man。　　For　this　reason　they　had　no　charity；
  for　charity　is　a　reverent　agnosticism　towards　the　complexity　of　the　soul。
  For　this　reason　they　had　no　such　thing　as　the　art　of　fiction；　the　novel；
  for　the　novel　is　a　creation　of　the　mystical　idea　of　charity。
  For　them　a　pleasant　landscape　was　pleasant；　and　an　unpleasant
  landscape　unpleasant。　　Hence　they　had　no　idea　of　romance；　for　romance
  consists　in　thinking　a　thing　more　delightful　because　it　is　dangerous；
  it　is　a　Christian　idea。　　In　a　word；　we　cannot　reconstruct
  or　even　imagine　the　beautiful　and　astonishing　pagan　world。
  It　was　a　world　in　which　common　sense　was　really　common。
  My　general　meaning　touching　the　three　virtues　of　which　I
  have　spoken　will　now；　I　hope；　be　sufficiently　clear。
  They　are　all　three　paradoxical；　they　are　all　three　practical；
  and　they　are　all　three　paradoxical　because　they　are　practical。
  it　is　the　stress　of　ultimate　need；　and　a　terrible　knowledge　of　things
  as　they　are；　which　led　men　to　set　up　these　riddles；　and　to　die　for　them。
  Whatever　may　be　the　meaning　of　the　contradiction；　it　is　the　fact
  that　the　only　kind　of　hope　that　is　of　any　use　in　a　battle
  is　a　hope　that　denies　arithmetic。　　Whatever　may　be　the　meaning
  of　the　contradiction；　it　is　the　fact　that　the　only　kind　of　charity
  which　any　weak　spirit　wants；　or　which　any　generous　spirit　feels；
  is　the　charity　which　forgives　the　sins　that　are　like　scarlet。
  Whatever　may　be　the　meaning　of　faith；　it　must　always　mean　a　certainty
  about　something　we　cannot　prove。　　Thus；　for　instance；　we　believe
  by　faith　in　the　existence　of　other　people。
  But　there　is　another　Christian　virtue；　a　virtue　far　more　obviously
  and　historically　connected　with　Christianity；　which　will　illustrate
  even　better　the　connection　between　paradox　and　practical　necessity。
  This　virtue　cannot　be　questioned　in　its　capacity　as　a　historical　symbol；
  certainly　Mr。　Lowes　Dickinson　will　not　question　it。
  It　has　been　the　boast　of　hundreds　of　the　champions　of　Christianity。
  It　has　been　the　taunt　of　hundreds　of　the　opponents　of　Christianity。
  It　is；　in　essence；　the　basis　of　Mr。　Lowes　Dickinson's　whole　distinction
  between　Christianity　and　Paganism。　　I　mean；　of　course；　the　virtue
  of　humility。　　I　admit；　of　course；　most　readily；　that　a　great　deal
  of　false　Eastern　humility　（that　is；　of　strictly　ascetic　humility）
  mixed　itself　with　the　main　stream　of　European　Christianity。
  We　must　not　forget　that　when　we　speak　of　Christianity　we　are　speaking
  of　a　whole　continent　for　about　a　thousand　years。　　But　of　this　virtue
  even　more　than　of　the　other　three；　I　would　maintain　the　general
  proposition　adopted　above。　　Civilization　discovered　Christian　humility
  for　the　same　urgent　reason　that　it　discovered　faith　and　charity
  that　is；　because　Christian　civilization　had　to　discover　it　or　die。
  The　great　psychological　discovery　of　Paganism；　which　turned　it
  into　Christianity；　can　be　expressed　with　some　accuracy　in　one　phrase。
  The　pagan　set　out；　with　admirable　sense；　to　enjoy　himself。
  By　the　end　of　his　civilization　he　had　discovered　that　a　man
  cannot　enjoy　himself　and　continue　to　enjoy　anything　else。
  Mr。　Lowes　Dickinson　has　pointed　out　in　words　too　excellent　to　need
  any　further　elucidation；　the　absurd　shallowness　of　those　who　imagine
  that　the　pagan　enjoyed　himself　only　in　a　materialistic　sense。
  Of　course；　he　enjoyed　himself；　not　only　intellectually　even；
  he　enjoyed　himself　morally；　he　enjoyed　himself　spiritually。
  But　it　was　himself　that　he　was　enjoying；　on　the　face　of　it；
  a　very　natural　thing　to　do。　　Now；　the　psychological　discovery
  is　merely　this；　that　whereas　it　had　been　supposed　that　the　fullest
  possible　enjoyment　is　to　be　found　by　extending　our　ego　to　infinity；
  the　truth　is　that　the　fullest　possible　enjoyment　is　to　be　found
  by　reducing　our　ego　to　zero。
  Humility　is　the　thing　which　is　for　ever　renewing　the　earth　and　the　stars。
  It　is　humility；　and　not　duty；　which　preserves　the　stars　from　wrong；
  from　the　unpardonable　wrong　of　casual　resignation；　it　is　through
  humility　that　the　most　ancient　heavens　for　us　are　fresh　and　strong。
  The　curse　that　came　before　history　has　laid　on　us　all　a　tendency
  to　be　weary　of　wonders。　　If　we　saw　the　sun　for　the　first　time
  it　would　be　the　most　fearful　and　beautiful　of　meteors。
  Now　that　we　see　it　for　the　hundredth　time　we　call　it；　in　the　hideous
  and　blasphemous　phrase　of　Wordsworth；　〃the　light　of　common　day。〃
  We　are　inclined　to　increase　our　claims。　　We　are　inclined　to
  demand　six　suns；　to　demand　a　blue　sun；　to　demand　a　green　sun。
  Humility　is　perpetually　putting　us　back　in　the　primal　darkness。
  There　all　light　is　lightning；　startling　and　instantaneous。
  Until　we　understand　that　original　dark；　in　which　we　have　neither
  sight