第 56 节
作者:
管他三七二十一 更新:2021-02-20 05:36 字数:9322
s。 Every discovery and act in society is necessary to him。 But of this immense quantity of products and ideas; that which each one has to produce and acquire for himself is but an atom in the sun。 Man would not be man were it not for society; and society is supported by the balance and harmony of the powers which compose it。
Society; among the animals; is SIMPLE; with man it is COMPLEX。 Man is associated with man by the same instinct which associates animal with animal; but man is associated differently from the animal; and it is this difference in association which constitutes the difference in morality。
I have proved;at too great length; perhaps;both by the spirit of the laws which regard property as the basis of society; and by political economy; that inequality of conditions is justified neither by priority of occupation nor superiority of talent; service; industry; and capacity。 But; although equality of conditions is a necessary consequence of natural right; of liberty; of the laws of production; of the capacity of physical nature; and of the principle of society itself;it does not prevent the social sentiment from stepping over the boundaries of DEBT and CREDIT。 The fields of benevolence and love extend far beyond; and when economy has adjusted its balance; the mind begins to benefit by its own justice; and the heart expands in the boundlessness of its affection。
The social sentiment then takes on a new character; which varies with different persons。 In the strong; it becomes the pleasure of generosity; among equals; frank and cordial friendship; in the weak; the pleasure of admiration and gratitude。
The man who is superior in strength; skill; or courage; knows that he owes all that he is to society; without which he could not exist。 He knows that; in treating him precisely as it does the lowest of its members; society discharges its whole duty towards him。 But he does not underrate his faculties; he is no less conscious of his power and greatness; and it is this voluntary reverence which he pays to humanity; this avowal that he is but an instrument of Nature;who is alone worthy of glory and worship;it is; I say; this simultaneous confession of the heart and the mind; this genuine adoration of the Great Being; that distinguishes and elevates man; and lifts him to a degree of social morality to which the beast is powerless to attain。 Hercules destroying the monsters and punishing brigands for the safety of Greece; Orpheus teaching the rough and wild Pelasgians;neither of them putting a price upon their services;there we see the noblest creations of poetry; the loftiest expression of justice and virtue。
The joys of self…sacrifice are ineffable。
If I were to compare human society to the old Greek tragedies; I should say that the phalanx of noble minds and lofty souls dances the strophe; and the humble multitude the antistrophe。 Burdened with painful and disagreeable tasks; but rendered omnipotent by their number and the harmonic arrangement of their functions; the latter execute what the others plan。 Guided by them; they owe them nothing; they honor them; however; and lavish upon them praise and approbation。
Gratitude fills people with adoration and enthusiasm。
But equality delights my heart。 Benevolence degenerates into tyranny; and admiration into servility。 Friendship is the daughter of equality。 O my friends! may I live in your midst without emulation; and without glory; let equality bring us together; and fate assign us our places。 May I die without knowing to whom among you I owe the most esteem!
Friendship is precious to the hearts of the children of men。
Generosity; gratitude (I mean here only that gratitude which is born of admiration of a superior power); and friendship are three distinct shades of a single sentiment which I will call equite; or SOCIAL PROPORTIONALITY。'1' Equite does not change justice: but; always taking equite for the base; it superadds esteem; and thereby forms in man a third degree of sociability。 Equite makes it at once our duty and our pleasure to aid the weak who have need of us; and to make them our equals; to pay to the strong a just tribute of gratitude and honor; without enslaving ourselves to them; to cherish our neighbors; friends; and equals; for that which we receive from them; even by right of exchange。 Equite is sociability raised to its ideal by reason and justice; its commonest manifestation is URBANITY or POLITENESS; which; among certain nations; sums up in a single word nearly all the social duties。
'1' I mean here by equite what the Latins called humanitas;that is; the kind of sociability which is peculiar to man。 Humanity; gentle and courteous to all; knows how to distinguish ranks; virtues; and capacities without injury to any。
It is the just distribution of social sympathy and universal love。
Now; this feeling is unknown among the beasts; who love and cling to each other; and show their preferences; but who cannot conceive of esteem; and who are incapable of generosity; admiration; or politeness。
This feeling does not spring from intelligence; which calculates; computes; and balances; but does not love; which sees; but does not feel。 As justice is the product of social instinct and reflection combined; so equite is a product of justice and taste combinedthat is; of our powers of judging and of idealizing。
This productthe third and last degree of human sociabilityis determined by our complex mode of association; in which inequality; or rather the divergence of faculties; and the speciality of functionstending of themselves to isolate laborersdemand a more active sociability。
That is why the force which oppresses while protecting is execrable; why the silly ignorance which views with the same eye the marvels of art; and the products of the rudest industry; excites unutterable contempt; why proud mediocrity; which glories in saying; 〃I have paid youI owe you nothing;〃 is especially odious。
SOCIABILITY; JUSTICE; EQUITEsuch; in its triplicity; is the exact definition of the instinctive faculty which leads us into communication with our fellows; and whose physical manifestation is expressed by the formula: EQUALITY IN NATURAL WEALTH; AND THE PRODUCTS OF LABOR。
These three degrees of sociability support and imply each other。
Equite cannot exist without justice; society without justice is a solecism。 If; in order to reward talent; I take from one to give to another; in unjustly stripping the first; I do not esteem his talent as I ought; if; in society; I award more to myself than to my associate; we are not really associated。 Justice is sociability as manifested in the division of material things; susceptible of weight and measure; equite is justice accompanied by admiration and esteem;things which cannot be measured。
From this several inferences may be drawn。
1。 Though we are free to grant our esteem to one more than to another; and in all possible degrees; yet we should give no one more than his proportion of the common wealth; because the duty of justice; being imposed upon us before that of equite; must always take precedence of it。 The woman honored by the ancients; who; when forced by a tyrant to choose between the death of her brother and that of her husband; sacrificed the latter on the ground that she could find another husband but not another brother;that woman; I say; in obeying her sense of equite; failed in point of justice; and did a bad deed; because conjugal association is a closer relation than fraternal association; and because the life of our neighbor is not our property。
By the same principle; inequality of wages cannot be admitted by law on the ground of inequality of talents; because the just distribution of wealth is the function of economy;not of enthusiasm。
Finally; as regards donations; wills; and inheritance; society; careful both of the personal affections and its own rights; must never permit love and partiality to destroy justice。 And; though it is pleasant to think that the son; who has been long associated with his father in business; is more capable than any one else of carrying it on; and that the citizen; who is surprised in the midst of his task by death; is best fitted; in consequence of his natural taste for his occupation; to designate his successor; and though the heir should be allowed the right of choice in case of more than one inheritance;nevertheless; society can tolerate no concentration of capital and industry for the benefit of a single man; no monopoly of labor; no encroachment。'1'
'1' Justice and equite never have been understood。
〃Suppose that some spoils; taken from the enemy; and equal to twelve; are to be divided between Achilles and Ajax。 If the two persons were equal; their respective shares would be arithmetically equal: Achilles would have six; Ajax six。 And if we should carry out this arithmetical equality; Thersites would be entitled to as much as Achilles; which would be unjust in the extreme。 To avoid this injustice; the worth of the persons should be estimated; and the spoils divided accordingly。 Suppose that the worth of Achilles is double that of Ajax: the former's share is eight; the latter four。 There is no arithm