第 10 节
作者:
敏儿不觉 更新:2021-02-19 00:57 字数:9322
his condition;〃 says a contemporary writer; 〃wants to be something
by command of the king。〃
It was not merely the 〃natural vanity〃 of which M。 de Tocqueville
accuses his countrymen; which stirred up in them this eagerness
after place; for we see the same eagerness in other nations of the
Continent; who cannot be accused (as wholes) of that weakness。 The
fact is; a Government place; or a Government decoration; cross;
ribbon; or what not; is; in a country where self…government is
unknown or dead; the only method; save literary fame; which is left
to men in order to assert themselves either to themselves or their
fellow…men。
A British or American shopkeeper or farmer asks nothing of his
Government。 He can; if he chooses; be elected to some local office
(generally unsalaried) by the votes of his fellow…citizens。 But
that is his right; and adds nothing to his respectability。 The test
of that latter; in a country where all honest callings are equally
honourable; is the amount of money he can make; and a very sound
practical test that is; in a country where intellect and capital are
free。 Beyond that; he is what he is; and wishes to be no more; save
what he can make himself。 He has his rights; guaranteed by law and
public opinion; and as long as he stands within them; and (as he
well phrases it) behaves like a gentleman; he considers himself as
good as any man; and so he is。 But under the bureaucratic Regime of
the Continent; if a man had not 〃something by command of the king;〃
he was nothing; and something he naturally wished to be; even by
means of a Government which he disliked and despised。 So in France;
where innumerable petty posts were regular articles of sale; anyone;
it seems; who had saved a little money; found it most profitable to
invest it in a beadledom of some kindto the great detriment of the
country; for he thus withdrew his capital from trade; but to his own
clear gain; for he thereby purchased some immunity from public
burdens; and; as it were; compounded once and for all for his taxes。
The petty German princes; it seems; followed the example of France;
and sold their little beadledoms likewise; but even where offices
were not sold; they must be obtained by any and every means; by
everyone who desired not to be as other men were; and to become
Notables; as they were called in France; so he migrated from the
country into the nearest town; and became a member of some small
body…guild; town council; or what not; bodies which were infinite in
number。 In one small town M。 de Tocqueville discovers thirty…six
such bodies; 〃separated from each other by diminutive privileges;
the least honourable of which was still a mark of honour。〃
Quarrelling perpetually with each other for precedence; despising
and oppressing the very menu peuple from whom they had for the most
part sprung; these innumerable small bodies; instead of uniting
their class; only served to split it up more and more; and when the
Revolution broke them up; once and for all; with all other
privileges whatsoever; no bond of union was left; and each man stood
alone; proud of his 〃individuality〃his complete social isolation;
till he discovered that; in ridding himself of superiors; he had rid
himself also of fellows; fulfilling; every man in his own person;
the old fable of the bundle of sticks; and had to submit; under the
Consulate and the Empire; to a tyranny to which the Ancien Regime
was freedom itself。
For; in France at least; the Ancien Regime was no tyranny。 The
middle and upper classes had individual libertyit may be; only too
much; the liberty of disobeying a Government which they did not
respect。 〃However submissive the French may have been before the
Revolution to the will of the king; one sort of obedience was
altogether unknown to them。 They knew not what it was to bow before
an illegitimate and contested powera power but little honoured;
frequently despised; but willingly endured because it may be
serviceable; or because it may hurt。 To that degrading form of
servitude they were ever strangers。 The king inspired them with
feelings 。 。 。 which have become incomprehensible to this generation
。 。 。 They loved him with the affection due to a father; they
revered him with the respect due to God。 In submitting to the most
arbitrary of his commands; they yielded less to compulsion than to
loyalty; and thus they frequently preserved great freedom of mind;
even in the most complete dependence。 This liberty; irregular;
intermittent;〃 says M。 de Tocqueville; 〃helped to form those
vigorous characters; those proud and daring spirits; which were to
make the French Revolution at once the object of the admiration and
the terror of succeeding generations。〃
This libertytoo much akin to anarchy; in which indeed it issued
for awhileseems to have asserted itself in continual petty
resistance to officials whom they did not respect; and who; in their
turn; were more than a little afraid of the very men out of whose
ranks they had sprung。
The French Governmentone may say; every Government on the
Continent in those dayshad the special weakness of all
bureaucracies; namely; that want of moral force which compels them
to fall back at last on physical force; and transforms the ruler
into a bully; and the soldier into a policeman and a gaoler。 A
Government of parvenus; uncertain of its own position; will be
continually trying to assert itself to itself; by vexatious
intermeddling and intruding pretensions; and then; when it meets
with the resistance of free and rational spirits; will either recoil
in awkward cowardice; or fly into a passion; and appeal to the
halter and the sword。 Such a Government can never take itself for
granted; because it knows that it is not taken for granted by the
people。 It never can possess the quiet assurance; the courteous
dignity; without swagger; yet without hesitation; which belongs to
hereditary legislators; by which term is to be understood; not
merely kings; not merely noblemen; but every citizen of a free
nation; however democratic; who has received from his forefathers
the right; the duty; and the example of self…government。
Such was the political and social state of the Ancien Regime; not
only in France; but if we are to trust (as we must trust) M。 de
Tocqueville; in almost every nation in Europe; except Britain。
And as for its moral state。 We must look for thatif we have need;
which happily all have notin its lighter literature。
I shall not trouble you with criticisms on French memoirsof which
those of Madame de Sevigne are on the whole; the most painful (as
witness her comments on the Marquise de Brinvilliers's execution);
because written by a woman better and more human than ordinary。 Nor
with 〃Menagiana;〃 or other 'ana'sas vain and artificial as they
are often foul; nor with novels and poems; long since deservedly
forgotten。 On the first perusal of this lighter literature; you
will be charmed with the ease; grace; lightness with which
everything is said。 On the second; you will be somewhat cured of
your admiration; as you perceive how little there is to say。 The
head proves to be nothing but a cunning mask; with no brains inside。
Especially is this true of a book; which I must beg those who have
read it already; to recollect。 To read it I recommend no human
being。 We may consider it; as it was considered in its time; the
typical novel of the Ancien Regime。 A picture of Spanish society;
written by a Frenchman; it was held to beand doubtless with
reasona picture of the whole European world。 Its French editor
(of 1836) calls it a grande epopee; 〃one of the most prodigious
efforts of intelligence; exhausting all forms of humanity〃in fact;
a second Shakespeare; according to the lights of the year 1715。 I
mean; of course; 〃Gil Blas。〃 So picturesque is the book; that it
has furnished inexhaustible motifs to the draughtsman。 So excellent
is its workmanship; that the enthusiastic editor of 1836 tells us
and doubtless he knows bestthat it is the classic model of the
French tongue; and that; as Le Sage 〃had embraced all that belonged
to man in his composition; he dared to prescribe to himself to
embrace the whole French language in his work。〃 It has been the
parent of a whole school of literaturethe Bible of tens of
thousands; with admiring commentators in plenty; on whose souls may
God have mercy!
And no wonder。 The book has a solid value; and will always have;
not merely from its perfect art (according to its own measure and
intention); but from its perfect truthfulness。 It is the Ancien
Regime itself。 It set forth to the men thereof; themselves; without
veil or cowardly reticence of any kind; and inasmuch as every man
loves himself; the Ancien Regime loved 〃Gil Blas;〃 and said; 〃The
problem of humanity is solved at last。〃 But; ye long…suffering
powers of heaven; what a solut