第 60 节
作者:
开了 更新:2021-02-18 23:01 字数:9317
Their feeble authority。… Insufficiency of their means of action。 …
The role of the National Guard。 …
Let us follow these municipal kings into their own domain: the
burden on their shoulders is immense; and much beyond what human
strength can support。 All the details of executive duty are
confided to them; they have not to busy themselves with a petty
routine; but with a complete social system which is being taken to
pieces; while another is reconstructed in its place。 … They are in
possession of four milliards of ecclesiastical property; real and
personal; and soon there will be two and a half milliards of
property belonging to the emigrants; which must be sequestered;
valued; managed; inventoried; divided; sold; and the proceeds
received。 They have seven or eight thousand monks and thirty
thousand nuns to displace; install; sanction; and provide for。 They
have forty…six thousand ecclesiastics; bishops; canons; curés; and
vicars; to dispossess; replace; often by force; and later on to
expel; intern; imprison; and support。 They are obliged to discuss;
trace out; teach and make public new territorial boundaries; those
of the commune; of the district and of the department。 They have to
convoke; lodge; and protect the numerous primary and secondary
Assemblies; to supervise their operations; which sometimes last for
weeks。 They must install those elected by them; justices of the
peace; officers of the National Guard; judges; public prosecutors;
curés; bishops; district and departmental administrators。 They are
to form new lists of tax…payers; apportion amongst themselves;
according to a new system of impost; entirely new real and personal
taxes; decide on claims; appoint an assessor; regularly audit his
accounts and verify his books; aid him with force; use force in the
collection of the excise and salt duties; which being reduced;
equalized; and transformed in vain by the National Assembly; afford
no returns in spite of its decrees。 They are obliged to find the
funds for dressing; equipping; and arming the National Guard; to
step in between it and the military commanders; and to maintain
concord between its diverse battalions。 They have to protect
forests from pillage; communal land from being invaded; to maintain
the octroi; to protect former functionaries; ecclesiastics; and
nobles; suspected and threatened; and; above all; to provide; no
matter how; provisions for the commune which lacks food; and
consequently; to raise subscriptions; negotiate purchases at a
distance and even abroad; organize escorts; indemnify bakers; supply
the market every week notwithstanding the dearth; the insecurity of
roads; and the resistance of cultivators。 … Even an absolute chief;
sent from a distance and from high place; the most energetic and
expert possible; supported by the best…disciplined and most obedient
troops; would scarcely succeed in such an undertaking; and there is
instead only a municipality which has neither the authority; the
means; the experience; the capacity; nor the will。
In the country; says an orator in the tribune;'21' 〃the municipal
officers; in twenty thousand out of forty thousand municipalities;
do not know how to read or write。〃 The curé; in effect; is excluded
from such offices by law; and; save in La Vendée and the noble is
excluded by public opinion。 Besides; in many of the provinces;
nothing but patois is spoken。'22' French; especially the philosophic
and abstract phraseology of the new laws and proclamations; remains
gibberish to their inhabitants。 They cannot possibly understand and
apply the complicated decrees and fine…spun instructions which reach
them from Paris。 They hurry off to the towns; get the duties of the
office imposed on them explained and commented on in detail; try to
comprehend; imagine they do; and then; the following week; come back
again without having understood anything; either the mode of keeping
state registers; the distinction between feudal rights which are
abolished and those retained; the regulations they should enforce in
cases of election; the limits which the law imposes as to their
powers and subordination。 Nothing of all this finds its way into
their rude; untrained brains; instead of a peasant who has just left
his oxen; there is needed here a legal adept aided by a trained
clerk。 … Prudential considerations must be added to their ignorance。
They do not wish to make enemies for themselves in their commune;
and they abstain from any positive action; especially in all tax
matters。 Nine months after the decree on the patriotic
contribution; 〃twenty…eight thousand municipalities are overdue; not
having (yet) returned either rolls or estimates。〃'23' At the end of
January; 1792; 〃out of forty thousand nine hundred and eleven
municipalities; only five thousand four hundred and forty…eight have
deposited their registers; two thousand five hundred and eighty
rolls only are definitive and in process of collection。 A large
number have not even begun their sectional statements。〃'24' … It is
much worse when; thinking that they do understand it; they undertake
to do their work。 In their minds; incapable of abstraction; the law
is transformed and deformed by extraordinary interpretations。 We
shall see what it becomes when it is brought to bear on feudal dues;
on the forests; on communal rights; on the circulation of corn; on
the taxes on provisions; on the supervision of the aristocrats; and
on the protection of persons and property。 According to them; it
authorizes and invites them to do by force; and at once; whatever
they need or desire for the time being。 … The municipal officers of
the large boroughs and towns; more acute and often able to
comprehend the decrees; are scarcely in a better condition to carry
them out effectively。 They are undoubtedly intelligent; inspired by
the best disposition; and zealous for the public welfare。 During
the first two years of the Revolution it is; on the whole; the best
informed and most liberal portion of the bourgeoisie which; in the
department as in the district; undertakes the management of affairs。
Almost all are men of the law; advocates; notaries; and attorneys;
with a small number of the old privileged class imbued with the same
spirit; a canon at Besan?on; a gentleman at N?mes。 Their intentions
are of the very best; they love order and liberty; they give their
time and their money; they hold permanent sessions and accomplish an
incredible amount of work; and they often voluntarily expose
themselves to great danger。 … But they are bourgeois philosophers;
and; in this latter particular; similar to their deputies in the
National Assembly; and; with this twofold character; as incapable as
their deputies of governing a disintegrated nation。 In this twofold
character they are ill…disposed towards the ancient régime; hostile
to Catholicism and feudal rights; unfavorable to the clergy and the
nobility; inclined to extend the bearing and exaggerate the rigor of
recent decrees; partisans of the Rights of Man; and; therefore;
humanitarians and optimists; disposed to excuse the misdeeds of the
people; hesitating; tardy and often timid in the face of an outbreak
… in short; admirable writers; exhorters; and reformers; but good
for nothing when it comes to breaking heads and risking their own
bones。 They have not been brought up in such a way as to become men
of action in a single day。 Up to this time they have always lived
as passive administrators; as quiet individuals; as studious men and
clerks; domesticated; conversational; and polished; to whom words
concealed facts; and who; on their evening promenade; warmly
discussed important principles of government; without any
consciousness of the practical machinery which; with a police…system
for its ultimate wheel; rendered themselves; their promenade; and
their conversation perfectly secure。 They are not imbued with that
sentiment of social danger which produces the veritable chief; the
man who subordinates the emotions of pity to the exigencies of the
public service。 They are not aware that it is better to mow down a
hundred conscientious citizens rather than let them hang a culprit
without a trial。 Repression; in their hands; is neither prompt;
rigid; nor constant。 They continue to be in the H?tel…de…Ville what
they were when they went into it; so many jurists and scribes;
fruitful in proclamations; reports; and correspondence。 Such is
wholly their role; and; if any amongst them; with more energy;
desires to depart from it; he has no hold on the commune which;
according to the Constitution; he has to direct; and on that armed
force which is entrusted to him with a view to insure the observance
of the laws。
To insure respect for authority; indeed; it must not spring up on
the spot and under the hands of its subordinates。 It loses its
prestige and independence when those who c