第 7 节
作者:无组织      更新:2021-02-17 22:57      字数:9322
  and the weight of learned opinion inclines strongly to the view
  that these rules had universally their source in Roman law; but
  were diffused by the influence of the Christian clergy。 This
  assertion cannot be quite so confidently made of Contracts; but
  the sacredness of bequests and the sacredness of promises were of
  about equal importance to the Church; as the donee of pious
  gifts; and; as regards the Brehon law; it is plain upon the face
  of the published sub…tract which is chiefly concerned with
  Contract; the Corus Bescna; that the material interests of the
  Church furnished one principal motive for its compilation。 The
  Corus Bescna; in which; I may observe; a certain confusion (not
  uncommon in ancient law) may be remarked between contracts and
  grants; between the promise to give and the act or operation of
  giving; contains some very remarkable propositions on the subject
  of contract。 Here; and in other parts of the Senchus Mor; the
  mischiefs of breach of contract are set forth in the strongest
  language。 'The world would be in a state of confusion if verbal
  contracts were not binding。' 'There are three periods at which
  the world dies: the period of a plague; of a general war; of the
  dissolution of verbal contracts。' 'The world is worthless at the
  time of the dissolution of contracts。' At first sight this looks
  a good deal liker the doctrine of the eighteenth century than of
  any century between the sixth and the sixteenth。 Let us see;
  however; what follows when the position thus broadly stated has
  to be worked out。 We come; in the Corus Bescna; upon the
  following attempt at classification; which I fear would have
  deeply shocked Jeremy Bentham and John Austin: 'How many kinds of
  contracts are there?' asks the Brehon textwriter。 'Two;' is the
  answer。 'A valid contract; and an invalid contract。' This; no
  doubt; is absurd; but the explanation appears to be as follows。
  The principle of the absolute sacredness of contracts was
  probably of foreign origin; and was insisted upon for a
  particular purpose。 It was therefore laid down too broadly for
  the actual state of the law and the actual condition of Irish
  Celtic society。 Under such circumstances a treatise on Contract
  takes necessarily the form in great measure of a treatise on the
  grounds of invalidity in contracts; on the manifold exceptions to
  an over…broad general rule。 Anciently; the power of contracting
  is limited on all sides。 It is limited by the rights of your。
  family; by the rights of your distant kinsmen; by the rights of
  your co…villagers; by the rights of your tribe; by the rights of
  your Chief; and; if you contract adversely to the Church; by the
  rights of the Church。 The Corus Bescna is in great part a
  treatise on these archaic limitations。 At the same time some of
  the modern grounds of invalidity are very well set forth; and the
  merit may possibly be due to the penetration of Roman doctrine
  into the Brehon law…schools。
  Something must be said on the extent to which Christian
  opinion has leavened these Brehon writings。 Christianity has
  certainly had considerable negative influence over them。 It
  became no longer possible for the Brehon to assert that the
  transgressor of his rules would incur a supernatural penalty; and
  the consequences of this were no doubt important。 But still; as
  you have seen; in the case of 'fasting on a man;' or 'sitting
  dharna;' the heathen rule remained in the system; though its
  significance was lost。 Again; one positive result of the
  reception by the Brehons of the so…called 'law of the letter'
  appears to have been the development of a great mass of rules
  relating to the territorial rights of the Church; and these
  constitute a very interesting department of the Brehon law。 But
  there has certainty been nothing like an intimate
  interpenetration of ancient Irish law by Christian principle。 If
  this kind of influence is to be looked for anywhere; it must be
  in the law of Marriage; and the cognate branches of Divorce;
  Legitimacy; and Inheritance。 These; however; are the very
  portions of the Brehon law which have been dwelt upon by writers
  convinced that; as regards the relations of the sexes; the
  primitive Irish were near akin to those Celts of Britain of whose
  practices Caesar had heard。 (B。 G。; v。 14。) The 'Book of Aicill'
  provides for the legitimation not only of the bastard; but of the
  adulterine bastard; and measures the compensation to be paid to
  the putative father。 The tract on 'Social Connections ' appears
  to assume that the temporary cohabitation of the sexes is part of
  the accustomed order of society; and on this assumption it
  minutely regulates the mutual rights of the parties; showing an
  especial care for the interests of the woman; even to the extent
  of reserving to her the value of her domestic services during her
  residence in the common dwelling。 One remark ought; however; to
  be made on these provisions of the Brehon law。 It is not
  inconceivable that; surprising as they are; they may be the index
  to a social advance。 Caesar plainly found the Celts of the
  Continent polygamous; living in families held together by
  stringent Paternal Power。 He; a Roman; familiar with a Patria
  Potestas as yet undecayed; thinks it worthy of remark that the
  head of a Gallic household had the power of life and death over
  his wives as well as his children; and notices with astonishment
  that; when a husband died under suspicious circumstances; his
  wives were treated with the same cruelty as a body of household
  slaves at Rome whose master had been killed by an unknown hand。
  (B。 G。; vi。 19。) Now; though very much cannot be confidently said
  about the transition (which; nevertheless; is an undoubted fact)
  of many societies from polygamy to monogamy under influences
  other than those of religion; it may plausibly be conjectured
  that here and there it had its cause in liberty of divorce。 The
  system which permitted a plurality of wives may have passed into
  the system which forbade more than one wife at a time; but which
  did not go farther。 The monogamy of the modern and Western world
  is; in fact; the monogamy of the Romans; from which the license
  of divorce has been expelled by Christian morality。 There are
  hardly any materials for an opinion upon the degree of influence
  exercised by the Church over the transformation of
  marriage…relations in Ireland; but there are several indications
  that the ecclesiastical rules as to the conditions of a valid
  marriage established themselves very slowly among the ruder races
  on the outskirts of what had been the Roman Empire。 Mr Burton
  ('History of Scotland;' ii。 213); in speaking of the number of
  illegitimate claimants who brought their pretensions to the Crown
  of Scotland before Edward the First; observes: 'That they should
  have pushed their claims only shows that the Church had not yet
  absolutely established the rule that from her and her ceremony
  and sacrament could alone come the union capable of transmitting
  a right of succession to offspring。' The tract on 'Social
  Connexions' notices a 'first' wife; and the recognition may be
  attributable to the Church; but on the whole my impression
  certainly is that the extremely ascetic form under which
  Christianity was introduced into Ireland was unfavourable to its
  obtaining a hold on popular morality。 The common view seems to
  have been that chastity was the professional virtue of a special
  class; for the Brehon tracts; which make the assumptions I have
  described as to the morals of the laity; speak of irregularity of
  life in a monk or bishop with the strongest reprobation and
  disgust。 At the present moment Ireland is probably the one of all
  Western countries in which the relations of the sexes are most
  nearly on the footing req