第 3 节
作者:
暖暖 更新:2023-08-22 20:48 字数:9320
at I venture to promise that it will be difficult for anyone to bring to mind criticisms of any consequence which have not been already touched upon。 This is why I beg those who read these Meditations to form no judgment upon them unless they have given themselves the trouble to read all the objections as well as the replies which I have made to them。6
Synopsis of the Six Following Meditations。 In the first Meditation I set forth the reasons for which we may; generally speaking; doubt about all things and especially about material things; at least so long as we have no other foundations for the sciences than those which we have hitherto possessed。 But although the utility of a Doubt which is so general does not at first appear; it is at the same time very great; inasmuch as it delivers us from every kind of prejudice; and sets out for us a very simple way by which the mind may detach itself from the senses; and finally it makes it impossible for us ever to doubt those things which we have once discovered to be true。 In the second Meditation; mind; which making use of the liberty which pertains to it; takes for granted that all those things of whose existence it has the least doubt; are non… existent; recognises that it is however absolutely impossible that it does not itself exist。 This point is likewise of the greatest moment; inasmuch as by this means a distinction is easily drawn between the things which pertain to mind that is to say to the intellectual nature and those which pertain to body。 But because it may be that some expect from me in this place a statement of the reasons establishing the immortality of the soul; I feel that I should here make known to them that having aimed at writing nothing in all this Treatise of which I do not possess very exact demonstrations; I am obliged to follow a similar order to that made use of by the geometers; which is to begin by putting forward as premises all those things upon which the proposition that we seek depends; before coming to any conclusion regarding it。 Now the first and principal matter which is requisite for thoroughly understanding the immortality of the soul is to form the clearest possible conception of it; and one which will be entirely distinct from all the conceptions which we may have of body; and in this Meditation this has been done。 In addition to this it is requisite that we may be assured that all the things which we conceive clearly and distinctly are true in the very way in which we think them; and this could not be proved previously to the Fourth Mediation。 Further we must have a distinct conception of corporeal nature; which is given partly in this Second; and partly in the Fifth and Sixth Meditations。 And finally we should conclude from all this; that those things which we conceive clearly and distinctly as being diverse substances; as we regard mind and body to be; are really substances essentially distinct one from the other; and this is the conclusion of the Sixth Meditation。 This is further confirmed in this same Meditation by the fact that we cannot conceive of body excepting in so far as it is divisible; while the mind cannot be conceived of excepting as indivisible。 For we are not able to conceive of the half of a mind as we can do of the smallest of all bodies; so that we see that not only are their natures different but even in some respects contrary to one another。 I have not however dealt further with this matter in this treatise; both because what I have said is sufficient to show clearly enough that the extinction of the mind does not follow from the corruption of the body; and also to give men the hope of another life after death; as also because the premises from which the immortality of the soul may be deduced depend on an elucidation of a complete system of Physics。 This would mean to establish in the first place that all substances generally that is to say all things which cannot exist without being created by God¥are in their nature incorruptible; and that they can never cease to exist unless God; in denying to them his concurrence; reduce them to nought; and secondly that body; regarded generally; is a substance; which is the reason why it also cannot perish; but that the human body; inasmuch as it differs from other bodies; is composed only of a certain configuration of members and of other similar accidents; while the human mind is not similarly composed of any accidents; but is a pure substance。 For although all the accidents of mind be changed; although; for instance; it think certain things; will others; perceive others; etc。; despite all this it does not emerge from these changes another mind: the human body on the other hand becomes a different thing from the sole fact that the figure or form of any of its portions is found to be changed。 From this it follows that the human body may indeed easily enough perish; but the mind 'or soul of man (I make no distinction between them)' is owing to its nature immortal。 In the third Meditation it seems to me that I have explained at sufficient length the principal argument of which I make use in order to prove the existence of God。 But none the less; because I did not wish in that place to make use of any comparisons derived from corporeal things; so as to withdraw as much as I could the minds of readers from the senses; there may perhaps have remained many obscurities which; however; will; I hope; be entirely removed by the Replies which I have made to the Objections which have been set before me。 Amongst others there is; for example; this one; 〃How the idea in us of a being supremely perfect possesses so much objective reality 'that is to say participates by representation in so many degrees of being and perfection' that it necessarily proceeds from a cause which is absolutely perfect。〃 This is illustrated in these Replies by the comparison of a very perfect machine; the idea of which is found in the mind of some workman。 For as the objective contrivance of this idea must have some cause; i。e。 either the science of the workman or that of some other from whom he has received the idea; it is similarly impossible that the idea of God which is in us should not have God himself as its cause。 In the fourth Meditation it is shown that all these things which we very clearly and distinctly perceive are true; and at the same time it is explained in what the nature of error or falsity consists。 This must of necessity be known both for the confirmation of the preceding truths and for the better comprehension of those that follow。 (But it must meanwhile be remarked that I do not in any way there treat of sin¥that is to say of the error which is committed in the pursuit of good and evil; but only of that which arises in the deciding between the true and the false。 And I do not intend to speak of matters pertaining to the Faith or the conduct of life; but only of those which concern speculative truths; and which may be known by the sole aid of the light of nature。) In the fifth Meditation corporeal nature generally is explained; and in addition to this the existence of God is demonstrated by a new proof in which there may possibly be certain difficulties also; but the solution of these will be seen in the Replies to the Objections。 And further I show in what sense it is true to say that the certainty of geometrical demonstrations is itself dependent on the knowledge of God。 Finally in the Sixth I distinguish the action of the understanding7 from that of the imagination;8 the marks by which this distinction is made are described。 I here show that the mind of man is really distinct from the body; and at the same time that the two are so closely joined together that they form; so to speak; a single thing。 All the errors which proceed from the senses are then surveyed; while the means of avoiding them are demonstrated; and finally all the reasons from which we may deduce the existence of material things are set forth。 Not that I judge them to be very useful in establishing that which they prove; to wit; that there is in truth a world; that men possess bodies; and other such things which never have been doubted by anyone of sense; but because in considering these closely we come to see that they are neither so strong nor so evident as those arguments which lead us to the knowledge of our mind and of God; so that these last must be the most certain and most evident facts which can fall within the cognizance of the human mind。 And this is the whole matter that I have tried to prove in these Meditations; for which reason I here omit to speak of many other questions which I dealt incidentally in this discussion。 MEDITATIONS ON THE FIRST PHILOSOPHY IN WHICH THE EXISTENCE OF GOD AND THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND BODY ARE DEMONSTRATED。9 Meditation I。 Of the things which may be brought within the sphere of the doubtful。 It is now some years since I detected how many were the false beliefs that I had from my earliest youth